Bake Off Bake Along
Comments 17

Mary Berry’s Jaffa Cakes | #bakeoffbakealong

Jaffa Cakes Bake Off Bake Along

Ohhhh it’s so good to be back here. It’s been a whole year since the first time I ever kicked off the bake off bake along on Cate in the Kitchen, knowing that this series is going to gently carry us through into autumn and leave us firmly in front of Christmas makes me happier than I can put into words. Ala and Amanda are once again hosting us all so I want to first say a huge thank you to them, it was so much fun to take part in 2015 and I predict much of the same for this year.

I’ll be approaching this blog series in pretty much exactly the same way as I did last year. A quick summary of my thoughts on that weeks show, followed by how I attempted one of the featured bakes. Even when a recipe is my own, I won’t be writing it up here (unless it’s unmissably outstanding) because I want to focus away from recipe development and hone in on the story of each bake. However, I will always direct you to recipes I used elsewhere on the web, and send you to the right pages of books, I’m not a total dick. Let’s go.

Mary Berry's Jaffa Cakes

  • The first thing to note: we have not found ourselves a Tamal replacement, have we. I’m sure I’ll grow to love each baker as I get to know them better, but I’ve not been struck by the love at first sight that I (and the rest of the internet) were subject to last year.
  • I haven’t remembered her name just yet, but I’m obsessed with the Granny who does a weird at-the-counter version of aerobics while she bakes, she is 100% me in 50 years.
  • Who on earth attempts a spherical cake that’s supposed to look like an orange in the first round on the first day? Brave girl.
  • I almost cried every time somebody had to restart their genoise sponge.
  • I’m like 83% sure that I will never ever attempt a mirror glaze.

As you can already tell, I went with jaffa cakes to kick off #bakeoffbakealong. Why? Three reasons. The first was that if I went with a drizzle cake, this post would feel too similar, I fear, to my madeira from last year. The second was because jaffa cakes are mad cheap to make, like mad cheap. The third: I have a friend I’m quite fond of who really really likes jaffa cakes. He didn’t get any in the end because he did something annoying so I ate them all, but the thought was there initially.

Mary Berry Jaffa Cakes

Let me just set the scene. It’s Saturday, it’s definitely somewhere over the twenty degree mark outside and inside is way hotter because I’ve already made a million naan breads and some chicken wings today. It’s hot, but I’m perfectly happy in my floaty dress (which is my favourite and I’ve worn it far too much all summer, you can see a teensie bit of it in the shot above) listening to Bomba Estereo a little too loudly. I read through the recipe for jaffa cakes properly for the first time since scanning it to work out what I needed to buy and breathe out a sigh of relief. This is really easy.

The first step is to make really, really strong jelly and then let it set in the fridge. A small hiccup for me at this point was my lack of anything functional in my home. All the baking trays are wonky and the fridge is tilted, so I ended up with a not at all uniform slab of jaffa jelly. Thankfully, I didn’t need anywhere near as much as the recipe called for, so when the time came I was able to pick and choose my cutting area to ensure consistent jelly disk thickness across all the jaffa cakes.

Jaffa Cakes

The cakey bit of jaffa cakes is so easy. Whisk a little bit of sugar with an egg quite vigorously until pale and fluffy, then very very gently fold in flour, and tip into heavily greased shallow cake pan. I got through this step with relative ease, but was met with a snag when it came to the tipping into the pan part.. Somehow (and I still have no idea how) I just didn’t have enough mixture for 12. I managed 10. If you can think of why this is, please let me know in the comments because I’m still confused!

Mary Berry's Jaffa Cakes

They bake for just under 10 minutes and come out looking something like the above. I was super nervous about getting them out of those little holes, but letting them cool for about 10 minutes and gently easing them out with a knife meant a clean break for each one.

Mary Berry Jaffa Cakes

Jaffa Cakes

I couldn’t resist using heart shaped cutters for the jelly discs even though nobody would know when they ate them..

Jaffa Cakes

I did not wait long enough for the chocolate to cool before putting it on top. At this point, I had grown impatient. This is my problem with baking guys, I have zero patience for all the waiting around between steps. This is what explains my messier-than-most presentation on the finished result.

Jaffa Cakes

Jaffa Cakes

They taste.. well, er.. they taste like jaffa cakes. Jaffa cakes without the bizarre dry syntheticness you can expect for something that needs to sit on a shelf for months on end. I’m pretty sure I’ll be making these again, and I’m hatching plans to make one giant one at some point too..

What do you reckon? What did you think of bake off this week? Talk to me.

Twitter // Instagram // Facebook // Bloglovin’ // Vine


  1. YAY! I love your Bake Off posts. Always a highlight! 😀

    These look like pretty good jaffa cakes to me! I’m not a fan of them myself (orange chocolate is the devil) but I definitely want to give that sponge recipe ago – sounds so easy! xx

    Little Miss Katy

  2. GREG says

    ha ha I love that granny as well . Her name is Val. Val to win. She listens to the cakes lol

  3. Well you’re completely ruining my not-doing-jaffas-because-I-like-the-weird-cardboard-texture-and-faux-jelly-combo approach to life but these look all kinds of awesome.
    I went all 1970s and chucked some Cointreau in a drizzle for my first ever bake along effort.
    And I loved Val, I might be team Selasi though. I’m totes enjoying feisty Berry though.
    M x

  4. Nice! Your Jaffa cakes look great, I was seriously tempted to make these too after watching GBBO but honestly was just too lazy!

  5. This looks lovely! I’ve had one jaffa cake once, but I don’t completely understand the British’s obsession with them haha
    Oh and I loved Tamal, had forgot him… I’m liking Selasi, though he’s hilarious 🙂 And I love the Granny (Val), she’s the one who listens to her cake, love it!

  6. I don’t know…I think Selasi could steal our hearts 😉 Or Val!! I have to say, your jaffa cakes look much better than the ones you buy in the store…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s